The homeowner's dilemma
It's the question every homeowner asks when facing aging windows: repair or replace everything? The answer isn't always obvious, and the window industry tends to push toward full replacement, a solution that is often more expensive than necessary. This guide will help you make an informed decision based on your actual situation.
In Quebec, a new mid-range window often costs $800 to $1,500, installation included. For a house with 15 to 20 windows, the bill quickly tops $15,000. By comparison, a repair (thermos, weatherstripping, hardware) most often costs a few hundred dollars per window, sometimes much less. The difference is major.
When a repair is enough
In most cases, your windows don't need to be replaced entirely. Here are the situations where repair is the better option:
The frame is in good shape
If your window frame (PVC, aluminum or wood) is structurally sound, with no rot, no significant warping and no major cracks, there is no reason to replace it. The frame is the most expensive part of the window and also the most durable. PVC frames can last 30 to 50 years, aluminum even longer.
Only the thermos is fogged
This is the most common scenario. The seal on the insulating glass unit has failed, condensation appears between the panes, but the frame and hardware still work well. Replacing the thermos (sealed glass unit) alone costs $149 to $400 per installed unit, a fraction of the cost of a new window. And the result is exactly the same: clear glass with good insulating properties.
The seals are worn
Weatherstripping and glazing seals are easy and inexpensive to replace. This is often the cause of air leaks that people wrongly blame on general window wear. Replacing weatherstripping costs $30 to $80 per window and restores the original seal.
The hardware is defective
Handles, multi-point locks, hinges, opening mechanisms: all these parts can be replaced individually. A window that no longer closes properly isn't necessarily a window to replace. It's often a simple hardware problem.
When replacement is necessary
There are situations where repair is no longer viable, and full replacement becomes the better investment:
The frame is rotten or badly damaged
Wood windows that haven't been maintained are the most likely to develop rot, especially at the bottom of the frame where water collects. If the rot is extensive and has compromised the frame's structural integrity, repair isn't realistic. Likewise, a severely corroded aluminum frame or a PVC frame that has yellowed, cracked and lost its rigidity means it's time for a change.
The windows are very old (single glazing)
If your house still has single-glazed windows (a single pane of glass, no sealed unit), replacing them with modern double-glazed windows is a very worthwhile investment. The difference in energy performance is enormous.
You're doing a major renovation
If you're undertaking a major renovation that includes wall insulation, new exterior cladding or structural changes around the openings, it's the ideal time to replace the windows too. Marginal costs are lower when the work is combined.
Water infiltration keeps coming back
If water seeps in around the window frame despite the caulking, there may be an original installation problem or advanced frame deterioration that calls for full replacement with an installation that meets current standards.
Comparing the two bills
Let's look at the numbers for a home in the Montreal area with 15 windows whose thermos units are fogged and whose frames are in good shape:
- Full replacement of all 15 windows: $12,000 to $22,500 ($800 to $1,500 per window)
- Replacing the 15 thermos units only: $149 to $400 per unit installed, which is several thousand dollars less in total
- Insulation achieved: similar in both cases when the frames are in good shape
The energy savings from a new thermos are practically the same whether you replace just the thermos or the whole window, since the glazing is responsible for most of the heat loss through a window. The frame plays a secondary role in insulation, unless it's in very poor condition.
Credits and grants
The Quebec government's Rénoclimat program provides $150 per opening for a door or window replaced with an ENERGY STAR certified model. It requires full replacement of the window, frame included: replacing the thermos alone is not eligible. The federal Greener Homes programs are no longer accepting new applications. The details are in our article on grants in 2026.
Even with the grant, full replacement is almost always more expensive than repair: $150 on a window costing $800 to $1,500 is 10% to 20% of the price. Do the math for your situation.
Our recommendation
At Vosthermos, our approach is simple: we always recommend the solution that benefits the customer most. If your frames are in good shape, we'll favour repair. If replacement is the better option, we'll tell you that too. Our assessment is free and with no obligation.
For an honest assessment of your windows' condition and a personalized recommendation, call Vosthermos at 514-825-8411. We serve Montreal, Longueuil, Brossard, Saint-Hubert, Laval and the entire South Shore.

